The information displayed here is for demonstration purposes only.
| name | category | nominated work | year |
|---|---|---|---|
| AARP Movies for Grownups Award | Best Supporting Actor | The Fabelmans | 2022 |
| Academy Award | Best Supporting Actor | The Fabelmans | 2022 |
| Drama Desk Award | Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | Knock Knock | 1976 |
| Golden Globe Award | Best Actor in a Television Series – Musical or Comedy | Dear John | 1988 |
| Indie Series Award | Best Supporting Actor (Drama) | Small Miracles | 2014 |
| Obie Award | Best Performance | Talley's Folly | 1979 |
| Primetime Emmy Award | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series | Taxi | 1981 |
| Primetime Emmy Award | Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series | Taxi | 1983 |
| Tony Award | Best Leading Actor in a Play | I'm Not Rappaport | 1986 |
| Tony Award | Best Leading Actor in a Play | Conversations with My Father | 1992 |
| Vanguard Award | The Fabelmans | 2022 |